Insurer Prevails in Vehicle Value Dispute

1

The insurance company explained that the adjustment had been communicated in a renewal notice in June, to which the policyholder consented upon purchasing the coverage. Although the car owner admitted to receiving this notice, she disclosed that she had not reviewed its content.

Challenging the new valuation, the policyholder contended that $29,700 was significantly below the market value of her car. She referenced sales listings for similar vehicles ranging from $35,000 to $44,000. However, AFCA clarified that the listings referenced do not accurately represent finalised sale prices, thereby undermining her argument.

According to AFCA, RAC Insurance's utilisation of the industry-standard Glass’s Guide for car price estimates was justified, describing it as a "reasonable sum". The authority noted it was the complainant's responsibility to read and understand the policy renewal notice.

The authority also highlighted that the cost of replacement parts alone was quoted at $29,880, validating the insurer’s decision to declare the vehicle a total loss. Although the policyholder's obtained quote was slightly lower at $27,161, it did not account for labour costs, and thus the repair was deemed economically unfeasible.

An AFCA ombudsman concluded that the insurer’s decision was fair and aligned with the policy’s terms, stating that the vehicle was uneconomical to repair, and the insurer was not obligated to undertake partial repairs.

Published:Wednesday, 23rd Jul 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

AFCA Rejects Traveller's Insurer Claim for Alternative Flight Costs 25 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori An Australian travel insurance policyholder faced disappointment as the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) denied their claim for reimbursement of costs incurred due to changing travel plans amid threats of a pilot strike. The traveller, who rearranged his flights from Sydney to Vancouver and subsequently to Toronto, had hoped his insurer, AIG Australia, would cover the $5,576 expenses for the rebooked flights and additional accommodation. - read more

Fee Models Emerge as Solution to Cyclone Insurance Affordability Concerns 25 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori The affordability of cyclone insurance in Australia’s high-risk zones remains a pressing issue, prompting some brokers to shift towards fee-based models. This change is highlighted in the latest annual review of the cyclone reinsurance pool from the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC). - read more

Homeowner's Storm Damage Claim Denied; Faulty Construction Cited 24 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori A homeowner's attempt to secure a storm damage insurance payout has been thwarted after an investigation revealed that the damage was due to poor maintenance and faulty construction, rather than extreme weather conditions. The initial claim attributed the damage on the property's western wall and roof eaves to significant rainfall, citing a substantial 141mm in July, with a notable record of 43.6mm in a single day. - read more

NSW Workers’ Compensation Scheme Faces Major Overhaul Amid Underinsurance Issues 23 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori The New South Wales State Insurance Regulatory Authority (SIRA) has identified critical issues of underinsurance and employer non-compliance within the icare workers’ compensation scheme. A recent review highlighted that over $60 million in premiums were not collected due to missing wage declarations, with about 75% of employers audited showing non-compliance responsible for an additional $24.5 million in unpaid premiums. - read more

Insurer Prevails in Vehicle Value Dispute 23 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori In a recent ruling by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), a protest from a car owner against her insurer, RAC Insurance, regarding the reduction of her vehicle's agreed value has been dismissed. The case arose after the complainant made a total loss claim following an accident in October, only to discover that her vehicle's value had been adjusted down to $29,700 from a previous total of $40,000. - read more